Choose the partner whose work you can check. Decide first whether you need strategy, execution or both, then ask every candidate the same questions about who does the work, what they measure, who owns the accounts, how you see the data and how you leave. Start with a paid audit or a small fixed-scope project, and keep every ad account, pixel and analytics property in your company’s name from day one.
If you can’t describe the job in a paragraph, every pitch will sound right. Write down four answers first.
Strategy is choosing which customers, channels, offers and budgets to bet on. Execution is building campaigns, making creative, fixing tracking and shipping landing pages every week.
Name the one or two where your buyers already are, say Meta and Google Shopping for a DTC brand, or Google Search and LinkedIn for B2B SaaS. Judge candidates on those channels, not their favorites.
A few hours a month of experienced judgment is a different purchase from 40 hours a week of hands-on work.
One business number, such as contribution margin from new customers or qualified pipeline, plus one leading indicator you check weekly.
Prices vary too much by market and seniority to list here, so compare quotes on the same scope: the total monthly cost of the work you described, including fees, setup, tools, creative and any minimum ad spend.
| Option | What you get | Typical commitment |
|---|---|---|
| Agency | Specialists, tools and creative capacity | Monthly retainer, often with a minimum term |
| Freelancer | One specialist’s hands-on time | Hourly, per project or monthly |
| Fractional lead | A senior lead who owns the plan and manages specialists | A set number of days a week or month |
| In-house hire | A full-time person building knowledge in-house | Employment, plus recruiting and ramp-up time |
When each one fits, and the main risk:
| Option | When it fits | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Agency | Proven channels that need media buying, creative and analytics at once | Senior people pitch, junior people deliver |
| Freelancer | One channel, a clear brief and someone in-house who sets direction | One person is a single point of failure |
| Fractional lead | You need direction and someone to run execution, part time | Limited hours, and someone else has to execute |
| In-house hire | Proven channels and a full-time job’s worth of work | Hiring before you know what the job is |
My default order: buy senior judgment first, through an audit or a fractional lead, then decide whether execution goes to a freelancer, an agency or a hire. A full-time hire for a job you can’t yet describe is the most expensive way to find out what the job is. We sell audits, so take that into account. If you already know the job and the channel works, skip the audit and start with a fixed-scope project.
Send every candidate the same questions in writing, so you compare answers, not pitches.
Ask for the names and roles of everyone who will touch your account, how many other clients each one runs, and who joins your weekly call. Ask the person who pitched how many hours a month they’ll personally spend on you. Put the lead’s name in the contract, with the right to approve any replacement.
Ask which number they’ll report every month and which system it comes from. For a DTC brand you want contribution after ad spend: revenue minus product cost, shipping, payment fees, returns and ad spend, ideally split by new and returning customers. For SaaS and AI products, you want qualified pipeline and closed revenue from your CRM.
Platform ROAS and lead counts are easier to hit. Each ad platform counts conversions under its own attribution rules and doesn’t see your margins or returns unless you send them, and a form can fill up with people who will never buy. More on this in how ROAS, MER and POAS differ.
You own the accounts and the partner gets access. That covers ad accounts, pixels, Merchant Center, analytics, tag manager, the store and the creative files, including raw footage and usage rights for creator content. Give each person their own login, never a shared password, so you can see who changed what and remove one person cleanly.
Agree the rhythm up front: a short weekly update on spend, results against target, changes and next steps, then a monthly review that ends in decisions. Ask for direct access to every ad account and analytics property, not just a PDF or a dashboard the partner controls. On Google Ads, Google’s guide for advertisers says you have the right to know at least the clicks, impressions and total cost of your ads, and its third-party transparency rules require partners to give you your customer ID on request and to report Google’s charges without their own fees mixed in.
Ask who makes the creative, how many new concepts they’ll ship a month and how they decide a test is over. A good answer names a hypothesis, a budget, a stop rule and a winning metric tied to margin or pipeline, not click-through rate. Landing pages belong in the same plan, since paid traffic sent to a weak page wastes budget (see landing pages for paid traffic).
Read the exit clause before the proposal. Ask for the minimum term, the notice period and what happens on the way out: who removes their access, which documents and files you get, and whether there’s any fee to get your own accounts back. The right answer to that last one is no. A short first term and clear notice protect both sides better than a long lock-in. If they’ll handle personal data for you, such as customer lists for Customer Match or Custom Audiences, UK and EU rules require a data processing contract. The ICO lists what it must cover, and the European Commission says it must state what happens to the data when the contract ends.
You’ll see three models.
Whatever the model, get fees and media costs on separate lines. On Google Ads, Google requires partners who charge a management fee to tell new customers in writing before the first purchase and to show the fee on every invoice.
Ask for two current clients like you in model and stage, plus one client who left. Call them. Ask who did the work, whether the partner’s numbers matched their own books, what happened in the worst month and how the handover went. If no former client will take your call, weigh that.
You should, on every platform. Create each account under your company, keep at least two admins of your own, and give the partner the least access that does the job.
Before a retainer, pay for something with a defined deliverable: an audit, or a short fixed-scope project such as fixing conversion tracking or rebuilding one channel’s account structure. You’ll see how the partner works, and you keep the output either way.
A good audit deliverable contains:
Score each candidate right after the call. Give 2 points when an answer matches the middle column, 0 when it matches the last and 1 for anything in between. A 0 on ownership or on reporting and data is a no, whatever the total.
| Area | 2 points | 0 points |
|---|---|---|
| Who does the work | Named people, known caseloads, the lead joins your calls | A team with no names |
| What they measure | Contribution margin or pipeline from your systems | Platform ROAS or lead counts only |
| Ownership | You own every account and file, they get access | Accounts sit in their name |
| Reporting and data | Weekly numbers, monthly decisions, direct access | PDFs and screenshots |
| Testing and creative | Written test plan, agreed creative volume, files handed over | Ad hoc tests, files kept by them |
| Contract | Short first term, clear notice, handover clause | Long lock-in with no exit terms |
| Pricing | Flat or hybrid fee, fees shown apart from media | Fees unclear or mixed into media costs |
| References | Current clients like you, plus one who left | Testimonials only |
| First project | Paid audit or fixed-scope project | Retainer from day one |
For a second opinion before you sign anything, our growth audit is $1,000 and takes two to three weeks, and the full fee comes off your first month if a retainer starts within 30 days. Retainers are billed monthly in advance and run month to month with 30 days’ notice, and every starting price is on our pricing page. Book a 30-minute call to talk it through.
The growth audit is $1,000 and takes two to three weeks. The full fee comes off your first month if a retainer starts within 30 days. Retainers run month to month with 30 days’ notice, and every starting price is on the pricing page.
Facts checked on 5 October 2026.